The Stereotypes of Going to Trial: What Really Happens in the Courtroom
When most people picture a courtroom trial, they imagine dramatic speeches, surprise witnesses, and lawyers pacing in front of the jury like something out of a TV show. In reality, the courtroom experience is far less theatrical — and far more procedural, strategic, and human.
While movies and media have shaped our perception of what “going to trial” means, the truth is that real-life trials are very different from what we see on screen. Let’s break down some of the most common stereotypes about going to trial — and what actually happens behind the scenes.
Stereotype #1: Trials Are Always Dramatic and Full of Surprises
In pop culture, trials are full of unexpected moments — the witness breaks down on the stand, the lawyer slams the table, or a last-minute piece of evidence changes everything.
Reality: Trials are built on preparation, not surprises. Evidence is disclosed well in advance during the discovery phase, and both sides generally know what’s coming. The best trial lawyers aren’t improvising; they’ve spent weeks or months preparing every question, exhibit, and argument.
Stereotype #2: Every Case Goes to Trial
Many people assume that filing a lawsuit means heading straight for the courtroom.
Reality: The vast majority of cases — civil or criminal — never make it to trial. Most are resolved through settlements, mediation, or dismissal long before a judge or jury hears a word of testimony. In Lemon Law, for example, most cases settle out of court, because both sides prefer a quicker, more predictable outcome.
Stereotype #3: The Judge Makes All the Decisions
Courtroom shows often make the judge seem like the all-powerful decider of every issue.
Reality: In a jury trial, the jury decides the facts — whether the defendant is liable or not — while the judge’s role is to make sure the law is followed and the process stays fair. The power is shared between law (the judge) and fact (the jury).
Stereotype #4: Trials Happen Quickly
On TV, cases often go from accusation to verdict in a single episode.
Reality: Trials take time — sometimes months or even years to reach the courtroom. The process involves pleadings, motions, discovery, depositions, and pretrial conferences before a date is ever set. Once the trial begins, it can still take several days or weeks to complete.
Stereotype #5: You Can “Win Big” Just by Going to Trial
People sometimes believe that going to trial guarantees a massive payout or complete vindication.
Reality: Trials are uncertain, and even a strong case can be risky. Juries can be unpredictable, and outcomes can depend on technical details or subjective impressions. This is why many experienced attorneys, including those at C&C Lemon Factory, carefully evaluate when settlement is the smarter move — and when trial is truly worth it.
Stereotype #6: Lawyers Always Argue Passionately in Court
The classic image of the fiery lawyer shouting “Objection!” is burned into our collective imagination.
Reality: Skilled trial attorneys are more persuasive through calm, clear logic and credibility than through emotion. Real courtroom advocacy relies on storytelling, evidence, and composure — not shouting matches.
The Truth About Going to Trial
Trials are not as glamorous as Hollywood makes them seem. They’re structured, methodical, and driven by preparation and facts. The real drama is in the strategy — in how attorneys craft arguments, build trust with the jury, and deliver justice for their clients.
At C&C Lemon Factory, our team understands both sides of the courtroom. Whether your case settles early or goes to trial, we prepare as if every case will be decided in front of a jury — because that’s how you get the best results.
📞 Call C&C Lemon Factory at (949) 535-1800 for a free consultation about your Lemon Law case and to learn whether settlement or trial is the right path for you.